The Deadly Companions (1961)

"You don't know me well enough to hate me that much.", 27 November 2015

The Deadly Companions was Sam Peckinpah's first non-TV directorial effort. Overall, I wasn't overly impressed. Peckinpah would go on to make some of my personal favorites, including The Wild Bunch and Bring Me the Head of Alfredo Garcia. But, unfortunately, I can't even call his first film "good".

The plot centers on an ailing ex-Army officer, called Yellowleg (Brian Keith), who accidentally shots and kills a young boy. The boy's mother, Kit Tildan (Maureen O'Hara), insists on traveling through dangerous Indian country so her son can be buried beside his father. To try to make-up for his mistake, Yellowleg travels with her despite her insistence that she doesn't need help.

The Deadly Companions has a number of problems I could cite (cheap sets, poor score, etc.), but I think I'll limit this to the biggest issue I have - the movie has a horribly uneven feel to the whole thing. For example, character motivation is all over the place. The ups and downs of Yellowleg and Kit's relationship feels so forced that it's more awkward than enjoyable. From one second to the next, you have no idea how they'll react to one another. It has a random feel to it like the script was being written and re-written daily (which I think was the case). The actors aren't helped by the ridiculous dialogue they're forced to spout. It's often embarrassing. And to make matters worse, I never felt any real chemistry between Keith and O'Hara. Being a pro, O'Hara is generally quite good, but it's not hard to see she would rather be anywhere else than on Peckinpah's set. Overall, it's a poor effort. If I have to come up one positive it would be Chill Wills in a supporting role. He's quite good.

4/10